Should You Accept the First Settlement Offer? What Happens If You Reject It
Home / Should You Accept the First Settlement Offer? What Happens If You Reject It
This page was written and reviewed by Michael J. Cefali, Esq. Attorney Cefali is a founding partner of Cefali & Cefali, APC, based in San Juan Capistrano, CA. He holds a Juris Doctor from Chapman University Fowler School of Law and a B.A. in Global Studies & Maritime Affairs from the California Maritime Academy. Widely recognized for his advocacy in personal injury law, he has secured multi-hundred-thousand-dollar settlements in motorcycle accidents, hit-and-runs, and red-light collision cases. He maintains a perfect 10.0 “Superb” rating on Avvo.
Beyond his legal practice, Mr. Cefali actively supports his community through the Rotary Club of San Juan Capistrano, contributes to housing and meal programs for those in need, and enjoys fishing and spending time with his rescue dogs.
The date below reflects when this page was last reviewed for accuracy. Please see our Editorial Guidelines.
Should You Accept the First Settlement Offer? What Happens If You Reject It
Rejecting an insurance settlement offer does not close your claim: the offer usually lapses, and the adjuster either returns with a better number, stands firm, or waits to see whether you sue. Turning down a first offer is common and rarely ends negotiations, but you should reject it in writing with a counteroffer, and you must keep an eye on the two-year deadline to sue, because talks with an insurer do not stop that clock.
Whether you should accept depends on one question: does the offer cover everything the injury will cost you, including treatment you have not had yet? After you sign a release, the case is over for good. This guide explains how first offers are built, when to say no, how to counter, and the California rules that change the math once a lawsuit is filed. It is general information, not advice about your specific claim.
What happens when you reject an insurance settlement offer?
Rejecting an offer usually leads to more negotiation, not a dead end. The insurer has already decided your claim is worth paying something, and a rejection backed by records tells the adjuster to revisit the number or explain why not.
Here is what typically happens next:
The original offer is off the table. Under California contract law, an answer that changes the terms is treated as a new proposal rather than an acceptance (Civil Code section 1585), so a counteroffer generally ends the old offer. Do not count on going back to it later.
The adjuster responds. Most insurers answer with a revised offer, a request for more records, or a letter saying the offer stands. Several rounds are normal.
If talks stall, a lawsuit becomes the next step. Filing suit does not mean going to trial. Most injury cases still settle, often after both sides exchange evidence and the insurer sees how a jury might react.
Nothing about rejecting an offer hurts your credit or your coverage. It is a normal part of the claims process.
Can an insurance company rescind a settlement offer?
Yes, until you accept it. A proposal can be revoked at any time before acceptance is communicated (Civil Code section 1586), so an insurer can withdraw or lower an offer, for example after finding a gap in your treatment or a social media post that undercuts the injury. Once you accept in writing and the terms are clear, the insurer generally cannot back out, and California regulations require it to pay within 30 calendar days of receiving your signed release (10 CCR 2695.7(h)).
What if there is no response to a settlement offer or demand?
Silence is not acceptance on either side. If you ignore an insurer's offer, it may lapse or be withdrawn. If the insurer ignores your demand, California's Fair Claims Settlement Practices Regulations require it to accept or deny a claim no later than 40 calendar days after it gets proof of claim, and to explain in writing every 30 days if it needs more time (10 CCR 2695.7(b) and (c)(1)). Follow up in writing, keep copies, and if the delay continues, a complaint to the California Department of Insurance or a lawsuit filed before the deadline usually gets a response. Typical timelines are covered in our article on car insurance claim timelines in California.
Should I accept the first settlement offer?
Usually not, unless your injuries were minor, you have finished treatment, and the offer pays all of your bills and lost income with something left for pain and suffering. First offers are an opening position, and adjusters expect a counter.
Insurers often make the first offer early, sometimes before your doctors know how serious the injury is. They may base it only on bills you have already paid, use software that discounts treatment it considers excessive, or assume you will take quick money over a longer wait. California regulations bar insurers from making offers that are "unreasonably low" (10 CCR 2695.7(g)), but in practice an opening offer is still built to leave room for negotiation.
A first offer can make sense in a narrow set of cases:
Your injuries were minor and have fully healed, and your doctor has released you.
The offer covers every medical bill, out-of-pocket cost and missed paycheck, plus a fair amount for pain and inconvenience.
The driver who caused the crash carries only minimal coverage, the offer already matches that limit, and no other policy applies.
Fault is seriously disputed and the offer reflects a realistic share of your losses.
Even then, have the release reviewed before you sign it. A standard release waives unknown claims under Civil Code section 1542, which means you cannot reopen the case if your condition later proves more serious than you expected.
When should you not accept a settlement offer?
Do not accept while you are still treating, before you know whether you will need surgery or future care, or when the offer ignores a whole category of your losses. A settlement is final, so accepting too early is the most expensive mistake an injured person can make.
Warning signs that an offer is too low or too early:
Red flag
Why it matters
You have not reached maximum medical improvement
Your doctors cannot yet say what future treatment, therapy or work limits you face. Some injuries, such as concussions and disc injuries, show up or worsen days or weeks later.
The offer arrives within days of the crash
Fast offers often come before you have records, a diagnosis or a lawyer. Speed usually helps the insurer, not you.
It only covers bills you have already received
Future care, lost earning capacity and pain and suffering are left out.
The adjuster pressures you to decide quickly
A reasonable offer does not need a same-day answer. Ask for it in writing and take time to review it.
Liens have not been accounted for
Health plans, Medi-Cal, Medicare and hospitals may be repaid from your settlement. A gross number that looks fair can shrink after liens and subrogation claims are paid.
Your losses are larger than the policy
If your damages exceed the driver's limits, other coverage, such as your own underinsured motorist policy, may still be available.
Minimum coverage matters here. California's required liability minimums rose on January 1, 2025, to $30,000 for one injured person and $60,000 for all injuries in a single crash. Serious injuries often exceed that, which is why we look at every policy that might apply, and why an early offer of "policy limits" deserves a second look. Our separate guide on suing beyond the policy limits explains when an insurer that turns down a reasonable limits demand can be held responsible for the full verdict.
How do I counter a settlement offer?
Counter in writing with a specific number, the reasons it is justified, and the records that prove it. A counteroffer that walks through the evidence is far more persuasive than a phone call saying the offer is too low.
Get the offer in writing. Ask the adjuster to explain how it was calculated, including which bills and which injuries were counted.
Gather the full picture of your losses. Medical bills and records, a doctor's statement about future care, wage records or an employer letter, receipts, photos of your injuries, and a short journal of how the injury affects daily life.
Pick a number with room to move. Your counter should be higher than what you would accept, but grounded in the evidence. A number you cannot explain gives the adjuster an easy reason to ignore it.
Write a short response letter. Say that you reject the offer, state your counteroffer, and list the reasons, such as treatment the offer ignored, wage loss, or the strength of the liability evidence. Our guide to writing a personal injury demand letter in California shows what to include.
Do not accept a verbal deal. Make sure any agreement is put in writing, and read the release before you sign it.
Calendar the deadline to sue. If you are getting close to the two-year mark under Code of Civil Procedure section 335.1, file the lawsuit and keep negotiating. If a public agency, such as a city, county or the state, shares the blame, a government claim is due within six months (Government Code section 911.2).
How to decline a settlement offer politely
A decline letter can be short. For example: "Thank you for your offer of $8,500 dated November 3. I am not able to accept it because it does not account for my ongoing physical therapy, the four weeks of work I missed, or my surgeon's recommendation for an injection. Enclosed are the records supporting these losses. I am willing to resolve this claim for $32,000." Keep the tone factual, avoid admitting fault, and keep a copy of everything you send.
After a case is in court, either side can make a formal settlement offer under Code of Civil Procedure section 998, and rejecting one carries real financial risk. A 998 offer must be made at least 10 days before trial and is withdrawn if it is not accepted before trial or within 30 days, whichever comes first.
If you reject a defense 998 offer and do worse at trial, you cannot recover your own costs incurred after the offer, you must pay the defendant's costs from the date of the offer, and the court may order you to pay the defendant's expert witness fees.
If the defense rejects your 998 offer and you do better at trial, the court may order the defendant to pay your expert fees, and in personal injury cases the judgment earns 10 percent annual interest from the date of your offer under Civil Code section 3291.
Because of these rules, a 998 offer should be weighed with a lawyer who can estimate the likely verdict range, not just compared with what you hoped to get.
Time-limited policy-limits demands (CCP 999 to 999.5)
Before a lawsuit is filed, a represented injured person can send the at-fault driver's insurer a time-limited demand to settle for the policy limits. Since January 1, 2023, Code of Civil Procedure sections 999 to 999.5 set the rules for these demands on auto, homeowner and commercial premises liability policies. The demand must be in writing, labeled as a time-limited demand, allow at least 30 days for a response (33 days by regular mail), offer a complete release of the insured, and include proof of the injuries. The insurer can accept, ask for more information or time, or reject the demand in writing and explain why. A demand that does not substantially follow these rules generally cannot be used later to argue the insurer acted in bad faith by refusing it, so these letters should be prepared carefully.
Talk with a lawyer before you accept or reject
A first offer is the insurer's opinion of your claim, not the final word. Michael J. Cefali and Courtney L.C. Cefali review settlement offers for injured people across Orange County and Southern California, and Michael's verdicts and settlements for clients total more than $60 million. Send us the offer or call (949) 325-7790 and we will review it at no cost, or visit our Orange County car accident lawyer page. Our fee comes only from a recovery, and we can often tell you within one conversation whether an offer is in the right range.
Settlement offer FAQs
What happens when you reject an insurance settlement offer?
The offer usually ends and negotiations continue. The insurer may raise its offer, ask for more records, or stand firm, and if talks stall the next step is a lawsuit. Reject in writing with a counteroffer, and remember that negotiating does not pause the two-year deadline to sue.
Should I accept the first settlement offer?
Usually not. First offers are opening positions and often arrive before your injuries are fully diagnosed. Accept only if you have finished treatment and the offer covers all of your medical bills, lost income and a fair amount for pain and suffering, and have the release reviewed first.
When should you not accept a settlement offer?
Do not accept while you are still treating, before your doctors can describe future care, when the offer leaves out lost wages or pain and suffering, or when liens have not been accounted for. A signed release is final, even if your injury later turns out to be worse.
How do I counter a settlement offer?
Send a written response that rejects the offer, states a specific counteroffer, and explains why with medical records, wage documentation and evidence of fault. Keep negotiating in writing, never agree to a verbal deal, and file a lawsuit if the deadline is close.
Can an insurance company rescind a settlement offer?
Yes, at any time before you accept it, under Civil Code section 1586. Once you accept in writing and the terms are agreed, the insurer generally must honor the settlement and pay within 30 days of receiving your signed release.
What is a 998 offer in California?
It is a formal settlement offer made under Code of Civil Procedure section 998 after a lawsuit is filed. If you reject a defense 998 offer and do not do better at trial, you can lose post-offer costs and may have to pay the defense's costs and expert fees.
Michael Cefali is a dedicated accident attorney based in San Juan Capistrano, California, committed to securing justice and fair compensation for accident victims.
A graduate of Newport Harbor High School, he went on to earn his Bachelor’s degree in Global Studies and Maritime Affairs from the California Maritime Academy, followed by his Juris Doctor from Chapman University School of Law.
Deeply invested in his community, Michael is an active member of the Rotary Club of San Juan Capistrano, contributing to efforts that provide meals, housing, and support to those in need. Outside of his legal work and volunteer service, he enjoys fishing in Dana Point and spending time with his three rescue dogs—a Chihuahua, a Spaniel mix, and a Shepherd mix.
Driven by his strong belief in justice and fairness, Michael remains steadfast in advocating for individuals harmed by the negligence or inaction of others.
Search Our Site
Schedule Your FREE Consultation
"*" indicates required fields
Practice Areas
Follow Us
Why Choose Cefali & Cefali Personal Injury Lawyers
We litigate and the insurance companies know it.
Unparalleled client communication leads to better results.
Down to earth attorneys who listen and care.
We get great results.
We have a fantastic team of paralegals and other friendly support staff.
We take the tough cases other firms reject.
No out of pocket - no win no charge.
100% free consultation
Contact Us Today
Start your no-obligation consultation with us by filling out the form below and we will contact you about your case within 24 hours.
