Which Car Insurance Companies Get the Most Complaints in California?

This page was written and reviewed by Michael J. Cefali, Esq. Attorney Cefali is a founding partner of Cefali & Cefali, APC, based in San Juan Capistrano, CA. He holds a Juris Doctor from Chapman University Fowler School of Law and a B.A. in Global Studies & Maritime Affairs from the California Maritime Academy. Widely recognized for his advocacy in personal injury law, he has secured multi-hundred-thousand-dollar settlements in motorcycle accidents, hit-and-runs, and red-light collision cases. He maintains a perfect 10.0 “Superb” rating on Avvo.

Beyond his legal practice, Mr. Cefali actively supports his community through the Rotary Club of San Juan Capistrano, contributes to housing and meal programs for those in need, and enjoys fishing and spending time with his rescue dogs.

The date below reflects when this page was last reviewed for accuracy. Please see our Editorial Guidelines.

Which Car Insurance Companies Get the Most Complaints in California?

The California Department of Insurance (CDI) ranks the state's 50 largest auto insurers by justified complaints, and in its 2026 Consumer Complaint Study the highest 2025 ratios belonged to State National Insurance Company (317.9 justified complaints per 100,000 vehicles insured for a year) and Tesla Insurance Company (142.2). Most of the other 48 companies landed between 0 and 11, and the middle of the list sat at about 3.

If you searched for the worst insurance companies in California, that study is the most reliable public answer, because it counts only complaints that state regulators investigated and found justified. Below are CDI's actual figures, what they do and do not measure, how to look up any insurer yourself, and what California law lets you do when a claim stalls. We do not rate insurers; every ranking on this page is CDI's. Treat it as general information; the right steps on a specific claim depend on its facts.

California driver reviewing a car insurance claim letter at a kitchen table

Which insurance companies are worst at paying claims?

No official California source ranks insurers on claim payments alone, so the closest measure is CDI's justified complaint ratio: the number of complaints the Department found justified for every 100,000 earned exposures (roughly, vehicles insured for a year). These are the 10 highest 2025 ratios in the study, which covers complaints closed in 2023, 2024 and 2025.

CDI rank (of 50)Company (as named by CDI)Approx. exposures2025 ratio2024 ratio2023 ratio2025 justified complaints
50State National Insurance Company, Inc.180,554317.999.655.9574
49Tesla Insurance Company261,688142.29.50.0372
48Knightbrook Insurance Company43,29323.117.337.610
47Integon Preferred Insurance Company191,01621.553.912.641
46Permanent General Assurance Corporation71,07018.310.219.513
45Loya Casualty Insurance Company213,75617.815.710.138
44Incline National Insurance Company71,19816.926.520.412
4321st Century Casualty Company236,03411.091.30.026
42Seaview Insurance Company54,66911.022.23.36
41Liberty Mutual Fire Insurance Company120,61410.85.05.413

Source: California Department of Insurance, Automobile Complaint Composite Report, 2026 Consumer Complaint Study. Exposures include motorcycles and motor homes. A higher ratio means more justified complaints relative to the company's size.

A few patterns stand out in CDI's numbers:

  • Two companies drove most of the 2025 total. The 50 insurers had 1,786 justified complaints in 2025, up from 1,388 in 2024 and 857 in 2023. State National (574) and Tesla Insurance (372) together accounted for 946 of them, about 53%.
  • Ratios can swing sharply from year to year. 21st Century Casualty Company went from 0.0 in 2023 to 91.3 in 2024 and 11.0 in 2025. Tesla Insurance went from 0.0 to 9.5 to 142.2. One year is a snapshot, so look at all three.
  • Four companies had no justified complaints in 2025: Essentia Insurance Company, GEICO Indemnity Company, Foremost Insurance Company Grand Rapids, Michigan, and GEICO Protection Insurance Company.
  • Ten of the 50 had a 2025 ratio of 10 or higher, while the median was about 3.

Complaint ratios for California's largest auto insurers

Most Californians are insured by one of the biggest companies, so the ratios that matter to most drivers are these. Here are the 10 insurers in the study with the most exposures, with their 2025 figures.

Company (as named by CDI)Approx. exposures2025 ratio2025 justified complaintsCDI rank (of 50)
State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company3,929,4523.112125
Geico General Insurance Company3,456,9912.06816
Interinsurance Exchange of the Automobile Club3,108,7681.34110
Csaa Insurance Exchange2,281,5061.63614
Mercury Insurance Company1,535,0431.2199
Infinity Insurance Company1,489,3362.63918
Allstate Northbrook Indemnity Company1,485,8832.63919
United Financial Casualty Company1,236,2522.83523
Farmers Insurance Exchange944,4563.73529
Aspire General Insurance Company745,6262.82122

Source: CDI 2026 Consumer Complaint Study, Automobile. Rank 1 is the lowest ratio and rank 50 the highest.

What the complaint ratio does and does not tell you

Under California Code of Regulations, title 10, section 2694, CDI deems a complaint justified when it finds the insurer did something such as violate the Insurance Code or regulations, act against the policy terms, depart from its own sales, underwriting, claims or service rules without good reason, or fail to answer a claim communication on time. The study's ratio is required by Insurance Code section 12921.1, which tells CDI to publish complaint records so consumers can compare insurers. Keep these limits in mind:

  • It is not only about claims. A justified complaint can involve premiums, cancellations, underwriting or customer service, not just how a claim was paid. The Company Profile search (below) breaks complaints down by type.
  • Only complaints filed with CDI count. Many drivers never file one, so the ratio measures problems that reached the regulator, not every bad experience.
  • Complaints count in the year they close, not the year they were filed.
  • CDI lists legal companies, not brands. One brand can sell through several companies. GEICO, for example, appears three times in the study under different company names, each with its own ratio.
  • Small companies move more. For an insurer with about 43,000 exposures, a handful of complaints changes the ratio a lot, which is one reason to compare all three years.
  • Only the 50 largest are ranked. Smaller insurers are not in the composite report, but their complaint records are in the Company Profile search.

How do I check complaint data?

Look up the company in CDI's free Automobile Complaint Composite Report, and if it is not one of the 50 listed, use CDI's Company Profile search and open the company's Company Performance and Comparison Data. Both are public and take a few minutes:

  1. Find the exact company name. It is printed on your declarations page and insurance ID card. Use that legal name, not the brand you see in ads.
  2. Check the composite report. Find the company's rank, its ratio for each of the last three years, and its number of justified complaints.
  3. Use the Company Profile search for anything else. Search the company name, then open Company Performance and Comparison Data to see complaints by type, outcome and year, along with its license status.
  4. Compare like with like. Line up the companies you are considering for the same three years, and give more weight to a pattern than to a single bad year.
  5. Ask questions about the data directly. CDI's composite page lists its Data Analytics and Reporting unit (Statreports@insurance.ca.gov) for questions about the report.

Nationwide complaint information is also available through the National Association of Insurance Commissioners' Consumer Insurance Search, but for a California policy, CDI's figures are the ones built from California complaints.

What about Insured Nation reviews?

Insured Nation does not appear in CDI's study because it is not an insurance company. Its own website says the operator is not an insurance broker or an insurance company, that it passes the information you enter to brokers or insurers, and that it is paid referral fees by insurance carriers. The same is true of many quote and comparison sites.

So when you read reviews of a quote site, remember they describe the website experience, not how claims get paid. The company whose name ends up on your policy is the one to look up in CDI's data and license search before you buy.

Person looking up an auto insurer's complaint record on the California Department of Insurance website

What can I do if my insurer stalls?

Put every request in writing and hold the insurer to the deadlines in California's Fair Claims Settlement Practices Regulations, title 10, sections 2695.1 and following. If that does not move the claim, file a free Request for Assistance with CDI, and if it is your own insurer delaying without a good reason, ask a lawyer whether you have a bad faith claim.

Key deadlines insurers must meet in California:

What the insurer must doDeadlineRegulation
Confirm it received the claim, tell you what proof it needs, and begin its investigation15 calendar days after notice of the claim10 CCR 2695.5(e)
Give a complete response to a letter or email that calls for one15 calendar days10 CCR 2695.5(b)
Decide whether to pay all, part or none of the claimWithin 40 calendar days of receiving your proof of claim10 CCR 2695.7(b)
If it needs more time, explain in writing what it still needs and whyBy the 40-day mark, then every 30 days10 CCR 2695.7(c)(1)
Pay once the claim is accepted30 calendar days (after a signed release, if one is needed)10 CCR 2695.7(h)

The same regulation bars an insurer from trying to settle with an offer that is unreasonably low (10 CCR 2695.7(g)), and a first-party denial must be in writing and list the reasons for it. Typical timelines for each stage, from inspection to payment, are in our California car insurance claim timeline guide.

When a claim stops moving, these steps usually help:

  1. Switch to writing. Email or mail the adjuster, keep copies, and note the date of every call. The deadlines run from when the insurer receives your communication, so you need proof of when that was.
  2. Ask what is missing. Request a written list of any documents the insurer still needs and the reason the claim has not been decided. If it has gone past 40 days without a decision or a written explanation, say so and cite 10 CCR 2695.7.
  3. Ask for a supervisor. Request the name of the claims manager and send your letter to that person as well.
  4. File with CDI. Use CDI's online complaint form at insurance.ca.gov or call 1-800-927-4357. Attach your claim number, a timeline and copies of your letters. If CDI finds the complaint justified, it also becomes part of the data in the tables above.
  5. Watch your own deadline. A slow insurer does not stop the clock on an injury lawsuit. The usual limit is two years after the crash, set by Code of Civil Procedure section 335.1; see our California statute of limitations guide.

Your own insurer versus the other driver's insurer

Who you can hold responsible for delay depends on whose insurance company it is. Your own insurer (collision, medical payments, or uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage) owes you a duty of good faith under your policy. The at-fault driver's insurer owes that duty to its own customer, not to you.

That matters because an injured person in California generally cannot bring a lawsuit against the at-fault driver's insurer over how it handled the claim. Insurance Code section 790.03(h) lists unfair claims practices, such as failing to act promptly on claims and not attempting in good faith to settle once liability is reasonably clear, but the California Supreme Court held in Moradi-Shalal v. Fireman's Fund Ins. Companies (1988) 46 Cal.3d 287 that it gives no private right to sue. CDI enforces it instead. Against the other driver's insurer, your real pressure points are a CDI complaint, a well-documented demand, and a lawsuit against the at-fault driver filed before the deadline. When an insurer refuses a reasonable offer within the policy limits, it can also end up responsible for a judgment above those limits; our article on suing for more than the policy limits explains how.

Bad faith basics in California

Every insurance policy in California carries an implied promise of good faith and fair dealing, and an insurer that unreasonably withholds or delays benefits owed under the policy can be sued in tort for breaking it (Gruenberg v. Aetna Ins. Co. (1973) 9 Cal.3d 566). An honest disagreement over the value of a claim is usually not bad faith; the question is whether the insurer acted unreasonably or without proper cause.

If bad faith is proven, a policyholder may recover the benefits owed, other financial losses the delay caused, the attorney fees spent getting the benefits (Brandt v. Superior Court (1985) 37 Cal.3d 813), and punitive damages under Civil Code section 3294 if the insurer's conduct amounted to malice, oppression or fraud. Bad faith claims have their own filing deadlines, so do not wait. Our guide to bad faith insurance claims in California covers the doctrine in more depth, and if you are weighing an early offer, read whether to accept the first settlement offer.

Stack of insurance claim letters and a calendar marked with California claim deadlines

Car Insurance Complaint FAQs

Which insurance companies are worst at paying claims in California?

No official source ranks insurers on claim payments alone. The closest measure is the California Department of Insurance's justified complaint ratio. In CDI's 2026 Consumer Complaint Study, the highest 2025 ratios among the 50 largest auto insurers were State National Insurance Company (317.9 per 100,000 exposures) and Tesla Insurance Company (142.2), followed by Knightbrook Insurance Company (23.1), Integon Preferred Insurance Company (21.5) and Permanent General Assurance Corporation (18.3). The median was about 3.

How do I check an insurance company's complaint data?

Use the California Department of Insurance's Automobile Complaint Composite Report, which lists the justified complaint ratio for the 50 largest auto insurers over three years. For any other licensed insurer, use CDI's Company Profile search and open Company Performance and Comparison Data. Search by the legal company name printed on your declarations page.

What can I do if my insurer stalls on my claim?

Put requests in writing and cite the Fair Claims Settlement Practices Regulations: an insurer generally must acknowledge your claim within 15 days, decide it within 40 days of receiving proof of claim (or explain in writing every 30 days why it needs longer), and pay within 30 days of accepting it (10 CCR 2695.5 and 2695.7). If that fails, file a free complaint with CDI at 1-800-927-4357 or online, and remember that the two-year deadline to sue for injuries keeps running.

Is Insured Nation an insurance company?

No. Insured Nation's website says its operator is not an insurance broker or an insurance company. It passes your information to brokers or insurers and is paid referral fees by carriers, so it has no CDI complaint ratio. Check the company that actually issues your policy.

Can I sue the other driver's insurance company for bad faith in California?

Generally no. The duty of good faith runs from an insurer to its own policyholder, and the California Supreme Court held in Moradi-Shalal v. Fireman's Fund Ins. Companies (1988) that Insurance Code section 790.03(h) does not give accident victims a private right to sue another driver's insurer. You can file a complaint with CDI and pursue your claim against the at-fault driver.

Talk with a California car accident lawyer

If an insurance company is delaying or underpaying your injury claim after a car accident, we can review where it stands and what the insurer owes you. Michael J. Cefali and Courtney L. C. Cefali represent injured drivers and passengers across Orange County and Northern California from our San Juan Capistrano and Pleasant Hill offices. Michael has recovered more than $60 million for injured clients.

Call (949) 325-7790 for a free consultation. You pay no attorney fees unless we recover money for you.

San Juan Capistrano - Office
27136 Paseo Espada, Ste 1123San Juan Capistrano, CA 92675
(949) 325-7790

Pleasant Hill Address - Office
2800 Pleasant Hill Rd, Ste 100Pleasant Hill, CA 94523

Hemet Address - Office
211 N State St, Ste 111 Hemet, CA 92543

Michael Cefali
Founding Partner

Michael J. Cefali is a California personal injury attorney with offices in San Juan Capistrano and Pleasant Hill. He has recovered more than $60 million for injured clients.

A graduate of Newport Harbor High School, he went on to earn his Bachelor’s degree in Global Studies and Maritime Affairs from the California Maritime Academy, followed by his Juris Doctor from Chapman University School of Law.

Deeply invested in his community, Michael is an active member of the Rotary Club of San Juan Capistrano, contributing to efforts that provide meals, housing, and support to those in need. Outside of his legal work and volunteer service, he enjoys fishing in Dana Point and spending time with his three rescue dogs: a Chihuahua, a Spaniel mix, and a Shepherd mix.

Driven by his strong belief in justice and fairness, Michael remains steadfast in advocating for individuals harmed by the negligence or inaction of others.
Search Our Site
Schedule
Your FREE Consultation

"*" indicates required fields

Full Name*
Required Fields *
Follow Us

Why Choose Cefali & Cefali Personal Injury Lawyers

We litigate and the insurance companies know it.
Unparalleled client communication leads to better results.
Down to earth attorneys who listen
and care.
We get great results.
We have a fantastic team of paralegals and other friendly support staff.
We take the tough cases other firms reject.
No out of pocket - no win no charge.
100% free consultation
Contact Us Today
Start your no-obligation consultation with us by filling out the form below and we will contact you about your case within 24 hours.

Footer Contact Form

"*" indicates required fields

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
Full Name*
Required Fields *
crosschevron-down